This Is NOT Your Parents’ 3% Down Payment Plan

In their latest Housing Market Insight & Outlook report, Freddie Mac revealed that recent low down payment initiatives have raised concerns that we may be returning to the same lax mortgage qualifications that caused the housing crisis from which we are just now recovering.

The report went on to explain that today’s underwriting guidelines are nothing like those that existed just prior to the housing meltdown.

“Pre-crisis underwriting allowed layered risk, that is, the combination of multiple features that amplified credit risk. Low down payments often were combined with variable-payment loan structures, property-based underwriting, and questionable appraisals. These risk factors, along with the ‘irrational exuberance’ of some borrowers, led to large losses during the crisis.”

What is layered risk?

In the pre-crisis environment, many mortgage loans incorporated several additional features besides low down payments that multiplied the total risk of the loans such as: variable payment options, underwriting based on the property not the borrower, questionable appraisal processes. Borrower expectations were also overly optimistic at that time.

Freddie Mac highlights the difference between then and now by using a table in the report:


By removing the “layered risk”, we can be confident that low down payment programs will not impact the market the way mortgage underwriting impacted the market a decade ago. And the report explains:

“Previous research has found that reduced down payments can increase the relative probability of homeownership among some groups by over 25 percent.”


We believe the report’s conclusion says it all:

“As long as the underwriting process bars the return of the layered risks prevalent in the pre-crisis era, lower down payments are not a cause for concern.”

16b4396d 449f 4d83 9818 5a2ebbcfcf93 f2b9dbaa ef8e 4922 9264 d74c6148649e 891895f6 d795 4de7 aae6 bc7b217e9c3a 6827ee57 1d64 4027 b118 2fb96da23d21 5712aa49 3936 4245 b583 c89f73817eca 103f8538 5270 4988 b863 733f47b82da7 0a7ccfd3 7725 4437 a78b aad0ae421100 7f877e47 0ba6 4b79 a981 0574aae67eeb 65301328 4441 4242 a2af fe72bee89451 9104c211 bfd1 43d8 ba16 6039e38d4df3 a46fcfab c034 4152 ad3a a4d645dc7ab0 ef08da91 fbc2 4345 bb3b 88f54a18d778 a0af59a6 5a19 483e b515 6f69f8d365b6 7a6dcc6a f37e 48cb 9d84 9123c7401fd9 b9caf5e7 4906 4006 a0d2 abcf272f96b3 fb691331 c2a9 4e77 bd2f a9c86451b1d0 6b56b72e 6ba9 4636 8345 9f580346d629 62da760b ad05 4f43 aa58 d41a6feeff55 58ae432f 2b04 4365 aaee 4bab20035e77 abeb6e74 00ee 49b9 9bdd d9d8140e8cc1 1e86dbb6 67c7 49a9 8c22 1d6b12580731 0f4acd41 191b 4dba a7bf 9b9727b1de41 b65c4404 2114 47cb 8b6c ebe2e6718094