The TRUTH Behind the RENT vs. BUY Debate

In a blog post published last Friday, CNBC’s Diana Olnick reported on the latest results of the FAU Buy vs. Rent Index. The index examines the entire US housing market and then isolates 23 major markets for comparison. The researchers at FAU use a “‘horse race’ comparison between an individual that is buying a home and an individual that rents a similar-quality home and reinvests all monies otherwise invested in homeownership.”

Having read both the index and the blog post, we would like to clear up any confusion that may exist. There are three major points that we would like to counter:

1. The Title

The CNBC blog post was titled, “Don’t put your money in a house, says a new report.” The title of the press release about the report on FAU’s website was “FAU Buy vs. Rent Index Shows Rising Prices and Mortgage Rates Moving Housing Markets in the Direction of Renting.”

Now, we all know headlines can attract readers and the stronger the headline the more readership you can attract, but after dissecting the report, this headline may have gone too far. The FAU report notes that rising home prices and the threat of increasing mortgage rates could make the decision of whether to rent or to buy a harder one in three metros, but does not say not to buy a home.

2. Mortgage Interest Rates are Rising

According to Freddie Mac, mortgage interest rates reached their lowest mark of 2017 last week at 3.89%. Interest rates have hovered around 4% for the majority of 2017, giving many buyers relief from rising home prices and helping with affordability.

While experts predict that rates will increase by the end of 2017, the latest projections have softened, with Freddie Mac predicting that rates will rise to 4.3% in Q4.

3. “Renting may be a better option than buying, according to the report.”

Of the 23 metros that the study reports on, 11 of them are firmly in buy territory, including New York, Boston, Chicago, Cleveland, and more. This means that in nearly half of all the major cities in the US, it makes more financial sense to buy a home than to continue renting one.

In 9 of the remaining metros, the decision as to whether to rent or buy is closer to a toss-up right now. This means that all things being equal, the cost to rent or buy is nearly the same. That leaves the decision up to the individual or family as to whether they want to renew their lease or buy a home of their own.

The 3 remaining metros Dallas, Denver and Houston, have experienced high levels of price appreciation and have been reported to be in rent territory for well over a year now, so that’s not news…

Beer & Cookies

One of the three authors of the study, Dr. Ken Johnson has long reported on homeownership and the decision between renting and buying a home. The methodology behind the report goes on to explain that even in a market where a renter would be able to spend less on housing, they would have to be disciplined enough to reinvest their remaining income in stocks/bonds/other investments for renting a home to be a more attractive alternative to buying.

Johnson himself has said:

“However, in perhaps a more realistic setting where renters can spend on consumption (beer, cookies, education, healthcare, etc.), ownership is the clear winner in wealth accumulation. Said another way, homeownership is a self-imposed savings plan on the part of those that choose to own.” 


In the end, you and your family are the only ones who can decide if homeownership is the right path to go down. Real estate is local and every market is different. Let’s get together to discuss what’s really going on in your area and how we can help you make the best, most informed decision for you and your family.

19b710d4 949b 4b00 885c 0e323d41a4c9 bb83f591 9fea 43ee b08e 5f43e76c2e9d 92c7a7b4 d6e3 46ac 90e3 e81092e7e137 74325bf6 7b37 41a4 8c5f 51487636c3b1 c616d52d 3530 4c43 b3c7 e524395c8b04 4be7ffdc 2fb8 4255 8853 65475df9a292 7acb3b48 d0b9 4144 977f 4512ffce8ef5 1e732bb5 254c 4803 8b9e 7bb19a8ab4b7 17ca99c3 f31e 4a3c 9ae6 61eac11abed8 9430db1b bd2f 4020 9382 f6490110ea36 f3cace8d 96c4 47d6 9d28 90a650f09296 b725948f c28a 42d4 9c53 aff26d2a9492 d93e0681 b929 40ff 99d1 d1a7efe22fa1 87c2278c 45aa 4b8e 8869 3fc1ede280ad 53020e83 4616 43dc b553 4004008b695a 8004da21 ea3c 4480 913f 3f64ef12500b fc28504a 46ed 46e7 810b 8a9f54742829 993e26e6 df36 4692 a995 67412fc4e2f8 82d321a2 bb9a 4116 a2fd ddbf22f85a7a cebe9157 1559 464f b484 c16029214372 effbcb73 2a66 4bc0 8b5a fe797d62d8ee 56b35cdd f305 4d1e 919e 7db9bd49015a 2008d3ac 5e72 47d7 bd25 eca012a1e319