Sellers Dilemma: OTM, FSBO or List Again?

At the end of June, in every region of the country, hundreds of homeowners have a tough decision to make. The ‘listing for sale agreement’ on their house is about to expire and they now must decide to either take their house off the market (OTM), For Sale by Owner (FSBO) or list it again with the same agent or a different agent.

Let’s assume you or someone you know is in this situation and take a closer look at each possibility:

Taking Your Home off the Market

In all probability, after putting your house on the market and seeing it not sell, you’re going to be upset. You may be thinking that no one in the marketplace thought the house was worthy of the sales price.

Because you are upset, you may start to rationalize that selling wasn’t that important after all and say,

“Well, we didn’t really want to sell the house anyway. This idea of making a move right now probably doesn’t make sense.”

Don’t rationalize your dreams away. Instead, consider the reasons you decided to sell in the first place. Ask your family this simple question:

“What made us originally put our home up for sale?”

If that reason made sense a few months ago when you originally listed the house, chances are it still makes sense now. Don’t give up on what your family hoped to accomplish or on goals your family hoped to attain.

Just because the house didn’t sell during the last listing contract doesn’t mean the house will never sell or that it shouldn’t be sold.

Re-Listing with your Existing Agent

For whatever reason, your house did not sell. Perhaps you now realize how difficult selling a house may be or that the listing price was too high, or perhaps you’re now acknowledging that you didn’t exactly listen to your agent’s advice.

If that is the case, you may want to give your existing agent a second chance. That’s a perfectly okay thing to do.

However, if your agent didn’t perform to the standard they promised when they listed your home you may want to either FSBO or try a different agent.

For Sale by Owner

You may now believe that listing your house with an agent is useless because your original agent didn’t accomplish the goal of selling the house. Trying to sell the house on your own this time may be alluring. You may think you will be in control and save on the commission.

But, is that true? Will you be able to negotiate each of the elements that make up a real estate transaction? Are you capable of putting together a comprehensive marketing plan? Do people who FSBO actually ‘net’ more money?

If you are thinking about FSBOing, take the time to first read: 5 Reasons You Shouldn’t For Sale by Owner.

List with a New Agent

After failing to sell your home, you may no longer trust your agent or what they say. However, don’t paint all real estate professionals with that same brush. Have you ever gotten a bad haircut before? Of course! Did you stop getting your hair cut or did you simply change hair stylists?

There is good and bad in every profession—good and bad hair stylists, agents, teachers, lawyers, doctors, police officers, etc. And just because there are good and bad in every line of work doesn’t mean you don’t call on others for the products and services you need. You still get your hair cut, see a doctor, talk to a lawyer, send your kids to school, etc.


You initially believed that using an agent made sense. It probably still does. Let's get together and discuss the possibilities.

42c04f58 97a1 4433 b15a 1eb1d9e6b4ba c0e002f6 f4b3 4a81 88f8 c6e8f85c517e efe90d42 de47 4f97 807c 882afcac4b97 f0553a8b 6144 4db0 8086 4c5c36069c00 c901833e 75cf 4a58 8e86 10245901519d 7e5b800c 6c96 4921 b9b5 ecef53334e78 75441df5 3702 46e3 b087 7a28a043ad43 91246bec 16eb 413a bf0a 8af837d31197 85ffa522 865a 4b7a a120 9ed55633a2fb 9f52b876 4905 45b8 a698 c5e079ea73aa fca9b530 16d4 4d02 b887 006c9cc8c09e d1fa0808 07e2 4331 a776 5edf9931322a 0b682c6b ee66 43db b7f0 80a041893a3c a6b44c2e 1dc1 4947 914b 98f26c4c3320 395f3aac dc9a 41d5 b707 fd21d7e661a4 017a83b2 c265 4e1d 81ab c912ecd76cde 60ba46ef 3c70 4a90 8de6 aeb3806672b5 a137f5e1 1f4c 46d3 9dff 678b0e2c68ed 3a80ab4c 0033 40ce b003 ffaa2fb44245 e2cd9fb3 e0fa 47e4 b8d4 20e9d790e11c b1e04679 2440 4ec3 a41a db4e883efa6a 53b74ff9 a2f4 4ca9 862f 97b9ead81006 9648d186 743c 447f 8f6a 9b324d794633